The Poetry Place

Personal Response - what's that about?

Both A level and GCSE place value on a ‘personal response’ from students but it’s often easier said than done.  Some students will need no encouraging to tell you or an examiner just what they think of a poem or a poet, from the ‘I love it, it’s great’ variety through to the ‘It’s rubbish. Why doesn’t he/she get a proper job?’ end.  Others will find it hard to make any personal response, not wanting to stray out of the comfort zone of things teacher has told them or points made on Bite Size.

As with so many things, it’s good to start young.  Before Secondary, of course! But certainly in KS3, asking students for opinions on what they read, be it prose or poetry. It’s always a two-part question: what did you think of X? Why / what makes you say that?  Another way into this is through prioritising.  Get them to list half a dozen or so poems in order of how much they like them.  (They can’t put them all at the bottom!)

Some students could be tempted into more sophisticated responses by being asked which poems they think are well written / have something important to say / will still be read in 20 years time, and so on – and making that a question alongside that of personal like/dislike.

Points to make with students:
  • You don’t have to like a poem (or a story, novel, play, scientific law, maths theorem) in order to appreciate it.
  • Outside of your friends (and your teacher, to some extent), no one is interested in whether you like or dislike a poem, just like that.  They are interested in why.
  • Some ‘why’ responses are more helpful / take you further than others. Because I don’t understand it / it’s boring gets you a little way, but needs more.  What makes it hard to understand / boring?  Similarly, what is it about the sound of the poem you like?  If it’s got good images, what are they, how do they affect you?
When it comes to examination answers, a brief statement – often towards the end of an answer – giving a personal response will be viewed positively by examiners. “Overall, I liked this poem because the rhythm, especially in the last two verses, makes you feel the movement of the sea, rather than just being told about it…”  Should the writer add a “However - ” they will be on the way to an even higher grade…

Search:


Archived blogs

   [OPEN/CLOSE]  How to...

   [OPEN/CLOSE]  Sonnets

   [OPEN/CLOSE]  Topics and themes

   [OPEN/CLOSE]  Parodies and homages

   [OPEN/CLOSE]  Different types of poem



Links

  • Poetry Archive

  • The Poetry Zone

  • Poetry by Heart

  • Forward Poetry

  • British Library

  • Poetryclass

  • The Poetry Society

  • Foyle Young Poets of the Year Award

  • Tower Poetry


  • We use cookies to deliver functionality and provide you with a better service. By continuing to browse our site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Find out more.

    Don't show this message again.